See Your Manufacturing Business Through an Acquirer’s Eyes

November 18, 2026 | Authored by Thomas J. Emmerling PhD, CFA®, CVA®

November 18, 2026 – Thomas J. Emmerling, PhD, CFA®, CVA® recently authored a guest column in Business First of Buffalo and the Albany Business Journal.

Dopkins logo, photo of Thomas J. Emmerling, text that says "WHAT'S YOUR COMPANY WORTH? SEE YOUR MANUFACTURING BUSINESS THROUGH AN ACQUIRER'S EYES" and "Thomas J. Emmerling featured in Buffalo Business First" and "CLICK HERE"

If you run a manufacturing company, you likely know what your equipment is worth. You can tell me the replacement cost of the CNC line, the age of the press, and the last time the oven was rebuilt. What you probably aren’t sure of is what a buyer will pay for the business that runs on them. Those are two very different numbers and it’s important to know why they’re different.

Owners tend to believe a business full of hard assets sells itself. Buyers see it differently. To a buyer, steel and square footage are not the value. They are the cost of entry. What they pay a premium for is the earnings those assets reliably produce, and how confident they are that those earnings will continue after you leave. Where that confidence is shaky, the multiple falls.

Buyers discount uncertainty.

Manufacturing has its own set of surprises, and every experienced buyer knows where to look. Customer concentration is the first. If one customer is 35% of your revenue, a buyer doesn’t see a customer, they see a risk they will price in. Deferred maintenance is next. The capital spending you may have postponed for years to keep cash flow healthy becomes the buyer’s problem, and then your price reduction. Add slow-moving inventory, work in process valuation issues, and the differences between your book earnings and your tax returns, and you have the makings of a re-trade. That is the quiet reduction in price that arrives after the letter of intent is signed, but before the purchase agreement is final.

The re-trade is almost always a preparation problem.

Most times a re-trade from a buyer occurs because diligence turned up something the owner didn’t know, or didn’t disclose, and the owner has no leverage left to push back. Once you’ve provided exclusivity through a signed letter of intent, the leverage shifts from the seller to the buyer.

Think about the questions a buyer will ask. Could your plant run for a month without you? Do you have a capable plant manager, a quality lead, and sales relationships that exist independently of you? Are your key machinists three years from retirement with no one behind them? Is your equipment’s true condition documented, or does it live in your head? Are your margins consistent by product line, or does one profitable job hide three that barely break even? Each unanswered question becomes a deal risk and a price adjustment.

Tariffs, supply chain shifts, and reshoring have made US manufacturers more attractive to buyers than they have been in years. That helps, but strong demand rewards the prepared far more than the unprepared. When several buyers compete, the business with clean financials, diversified customers and vendors, documented processes, and a strong management team gets the best terms. It’s that straightforward.

Setting your own pace and timeline

Big risk issues cannot be solved in the sixty days of due diligence. Reducing customer concentration takes years. Building a strong management team is no small initiative. Catching up on capital investment, cleaning up job costing, and commissioning a sell-side quality of earnings review all take time, and they work best when no buyer is watching. The manufacturers who command premium valuations didn’t get lucky. They started this work years before they needed to.

This fact should motivate you. Every one of these gaps is fixable, and every fix pays you twice: first in a stronger business while you own it, then in a higher price when you sell it.

So the next time a buyer calls to tell you how impressive your plant is, remember that they’re being polite, not generous. The real question is whether your business can hold up when they look at everything else.

For more information, contact Thomas J. Emmerling, PhD, CFA®, CVA® at tjemmerling@dopkins.com.

To read the article on the Business First of Buffalo website, click here.  

Dopkins Capital Advisors provides clients with comprehensive services covering mergers and acquisitions, business valuations, and business exit planning and execution. Our team of financial professionals, with focused expertise in accounting, tax advisory, investment banking, and wealth management, create a leverageable ecosystem to provide a full suite of capital advisory services.

Dopkins & Company, LLP also offers comprehensive accounting, auditing and tax services, forensic accounting, outsourced accounting, as well as wealth management consulting, internal audit support and capital advisory services to privately held and public companies, not-for-profit organizations and individuals.

Inside Public Accounting Best of the Best Firms logo for 2025Dopkins is proud to be named a 2025 ‘Best of the Best’ Firm by Inside Public Accounting
Recognized for the second consecutive year as one of just 60 firms nationwide in its category.

READ MORE

 

 

This article is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, valuation, investment banking, or transaction advice. Business owners should consult appropriate professional advisors regarding their individual circumstances. Securities offered through Realta Equities, Inc., Member FINRA/SIPC. Realta Equities, Inc. is located at 1202 N. Orange Street, Suite 729, Wilmington, DE 19801. Realta is not affiliated with Buffalo Business First or Dopkins & Company, LLP.

About the Author

Thomas J. Emmerling PhD, CFA®, CVA®

Tom counsels clients in exit planning and mergers and acquisitions, helping them navigate the complex and often lengthy process as businesses are transitioned to new ownership.

Do What You Love.
Love What You Do.

It’s about balance. The variety and quality of the clients, along with access to the latest technology and business information keeps the work interesting.

Learn More
Three Dopkins Employees

Opportunity Awaits

Take your career to the next level at Dopkins

Learn more